5

My Question of the Day for 05 January 2010

-

My Question of the Day: Is it better to learn from other people’s experiences or to experience things for yourself?

(this question was inspired by a quote tweeted by @williecolon on 04 Jan 2010; thanks!)

RULES FOR COMMENTS

1. DO NOT include links in your post. There is a place for you to include one link when you’re filling out the Name/Email/Website information. Comments that include links will be deleted.

2. If your post is obviously irrelevant to the question at hand, it will be deleted. This is a tactic spammers use to simply show up on blogs.

3. Please keep your comments respectful. We can agree to disagree without attacking each other.

FYI: You may edit your comment for up to 30 minutes after posting. After 30 minutes, your comment can no longer be revised.

0

My Question of the Day for 04 January 2010 – RESULTS

-

The Question: You decide to go out to the 24-hour supermarket late at night to pick up a few things to avoid the crowds. You park and begin walking toward the store. As you pass the back of one particular vehicle, movement catches your eye, and you look toward the car windows. As you walk closer to the car, you discern that all the windows are shut tight. When you get close enough to actually see through the windows, you realize there are three small children, all in pajamas, unattended and sleeping in the back seat of the vehicle. What do you do?

My 2 Cents: Seeing unattended children in a parked car late at night with the windows completely shut would disturb me, but my mind would most likely first go to the best-case scenario in this situation. Maybe the parent(s) just needed to dash into the store very quickly to grab one or two things, and s/he didn’t want to leave his/her small children in the house unattended. Maybe s/he thought it would be better to bring the sleeping children along in the car, because they would be closer if there was a problem.

Having thought that, my mind would most likely then wander over to the worst-case scenario. The parent of these children actually works at the store and can’t afford childcare, so s/he brings them to his/her job each night s/he has to work and leaves them in the car while s/he works his/her shift. Nothing has happened so far, but what happens when something unfortunate does happen; the car is hit by some careless person not paying attention or under the influence of mind-altering substances; someone steals the car and doesn’t realize there are children in the back seat; someone breaks into the car and abducts one or all of the children; with the windows shut tightly there isn’t enough air and the children never wake up?

Regardless of what I’m thinking, I’ll have to say that I’d most likely do a combination of what @JoshDamage and @ObiOrion suggested. I’d go on into the store and get what I came to get. If the children were still in the car and unattended when I finished shopping, I’d go back into the store and report the situation to the supervisor on duty. If there was no supervisor on duty, and no one could/would claim responsibility for the children in the car, I’d then call 911 and report the incident.

I couldn’t just drive away thinking, “Well, that’s none of my business. I don’t really know what’s going on, so I don’t want to get anyone in trouble.” No way. Knowing I walked away and did nothing would eat at me for days. I may have done more harm than good by taking the stance that it was none of my business. How would I feel if I turned on the news and heard a story about three small children being left in a car and harmed in some way? Uh-uh. If I err on the side of caution, and attempt to seek capable supervision for these children, then the blood would be off my hands. If I just walk on by and do nothing, I’m just as responsible as the person who left those children in the car and unattended.

If it takes a village, let’s start acting that way.

Check out some articles on this subject:

Children Left In Car During Cold Day <– This was reported on 17 Decemeber 2009

Caretaker of dead Jacksonville boy previously cited for supervision issues

Child dies in Ellicott City after being left in hot car <– Ellicott City is about an hour’s drive away from where I live.

Hyperthermia Deaths of Children in Vehicles <– Interesting Fact Sheet
———-

Take a few moments to check out the tweets from Twitter on this subject:

———-

Mitch Mitchell Mitch_M  I call 911.

Darryl Mims Write_Of_Fusion  Oh heck no! I go straight to the manager, tell him what the deal is, and go back to wait by their car for the police or parent.

MusingMom MusingMom  call the police, stay there with the car and talk to kids until police arrive….mandated reporter

Jason L. Wilson iJustJason  assume parent ran in real quick & will be back very shortly. If still not back by the time YOU return, tell security

Aqiyl Qasim consciousskillz  For the first time I don’t have a comment. You really pose some thought provoking questions.

MsShana MissMeandI  Probably nothing. But then I’m not one to go to the store in the middle of the night (Honestly I don’t know)

Tomi Clark tclarkusa  I’d prob wait awhile & later call 911 & report it. Praying I did right thing.

Nancy Welker NancyWelker  I would go back to my car, sit there and wait for an adult to come back to the kids. If no one came in an hour I’d call 911.

Orion Dauphin ObiOrion  Notify the store manager to send an announcement over the PA system. If no response then escalate.

lt md20737  I dont even know..

David Bass davidsbass  Easy. Don’t leave the children. Point at them, face the convenience store, YELL “WHOSE KIDS ARE THESE?” Get your cellphone.

Joshua Gibson JoshDamage  Conduct my business and if they are still in the car when I come out call the authorities…

———-

Also check out comments from my personal Facebook account.

———-

C.H. –> Call the police. Child endagerment!

K.B. –> I’ll start by saying that this is a very dangerous situation. BUT most peoples answers will be based on their life experiences. I can see how the situation could happen and both understand AND disagree with it. I wouldn’t leave MY kids unless I have no other alternative.
 
D.D. –> Monitor the car for a few minutes. If no adult returns, contact the police. If the adult returns have a “difficult” conversation.
 
B.P. –> Don’t confront anyone. Call the police.
 
T.R. –> Yep..let the police know…asap…

The commentary doesn’t have to end!

———-

And, here are more comments from my public Facebook account.

———-

R.M. –> Is this what happened when you went to the supermarket? Maybe the parent works there overnight & has no other babysitter arrangements then again maybe the parent was in the store buying something real quick. I would have to think before I acted on that one even I would’nt leave my kids like that if I had any.

E.M. –> Looks like a case of quick shopping to me (and no baby sitters) but to be on the safe side, i would ask the supermarket to make call asking for the driver of the car to come forward so they can advise driver. No response & I would call the authorities.
 
B.M. –> As for me, as a single parent, there have been times that has been a necessary evil. Being protective as I am of my own, I also have been known to step in and protect others’ kids when they are unable. I’d do that by standing next to the car until the parent came out, watching over the kids to ensure that they would remain safe. The parent might seem apprehensive at first that someone is standing next to her car, but might appreciate that someone was watching over the kids on her behalf. I personally would appreciate not having someone run to report me to the authorities.
 
E.M. –> I don’t think running to the authorities would be the 1st step as many people are very understanding in these situations but strange things & awful news have been known to happen. Other than getting the supermarket to call them and draw the parent’s attention to the problem, it’s sort of hard to know where to draw the line. How long do you wait by the car for? What if you’re in a hurry yourself? Do you just breeze past and hope for the best? What if the kids are in non visible danger? Tough one – but I guess with the world being the way it is these days, better be safe than sorry?
 
B.M. –> OF course I wouldn’t stay forever, I would set a reasonable time limit (15 minutes or so), because there is a limit to how long you should leave those kids unattended before taking further action (having parents paged in store, for instance) and before calling in the cavalry.
———-

The discussion doesn’t have to end!

Please feel free to continue to add your comments below.

Please note that I will be picking winners for the months in 2011 that have not been done yet. I've gotten behind, but I'm a woman of my word. Beginning, 01 January 2012, there will only be one winner per month, and that one winner will receive a $30 Amazon gift card. For the months in 2011 that still need winners, there will still be two, $20 gift card winners. The change will take effect starting 01 January 2012. See details.
http://downloadpart.com